Gloss is the total amount of specular reflection; The clarity of DOI refers to the micro flatness and image sharpness of shortwave waves. Barium sulfate (especially natural barium and ordinary precipitated barium) lowers DOI, and often the luster looks good, but the reflection becomes blurred, foggy, and the edges are blurred. The root cause is the particle morphology, particle size distribution, oil absorption, dispersion, and surface modification. Natural barium is a congenital weakness, while ordinary precipitated barium is due to incorrect brand selection/dispersion.
BaSO ₄ refractive index ≈ 1.64, resin is generally 1.49-1.55, which will generate interface scattering itself; It’s not a matter of covering power, it’s a combination of micro fluctuations and micro scattering.
1、 Why does natural barium sulfate (barite powder) have poor luster and DOI
1. Appearance: Angular, cleavage step, broken section of ore crushing, particles are irregular angular, not round particles. After the film shrinks, the edges will protrude nanometer to micrometer level short wave protrusions, directly scattering the reflected light and causing a sharp drop in DOI; Edges can also hinder the leveling of wet film, and the orange peel and short wave ripples are aggravated.
2. Wide particle size distribution, coarse tail (D90/D97) is a killer even if D50 reaches 1.5 μ m, D97 often has 3-8 μ m, and a small amount of large particles form scattering points on the surface of the paint film; The destructive force of coarse particles on DOI is much greater than the average particle size.
3. High impurities: Quartz, mica, and iron oxide quartz have higher hardness and sharper particles; Iron impurities bring yellow phase and uneven local scattering, causing the surface of the board to become blurred and foggy.
4. High oil absorption, hydrophilic surface, difficult to wet unmodified barite with high surface polarity, poor resin wetting, and easy coagulation and aggregation; Aggregates are microscopic protrusions that directly destroy DOI; High oil absorption will compete for resin, resulting in insufficient resin in some areas and poor film density and leveling.
Conclusion: Natural barium is suitable for primer, matte, and anti-corrosion; High gloss topcoat and high DOI topcoat are not suitable, and the upper limit is very low.
2、 Precipitation of barium sulfate, even though it is a chemical synthesis, why does it still have poor DOI
The precipitation of barium itself is controllable, but the vast majority of ordinary precipitation barium on the market is not of high gloss DOI grade:
1. If the crystal morphology is not well controlled, the precipitation of barium by ordinary saltpeter method is prone to flaky, rod-shaped, and agglomerated hard clusters; The high-end highlight model is spherical in shape, with controllable crystal structure and narrow distribution. Flake barium can also cause surface undulations.
2. Wide particle size distribution, uncontrolled growth of crystal nuclei, uncontrolled reaction droplet acceleration rate, concentration, pH, and mixed particles of different sizes; Small particles have a large specific surface area, high oil absorption, and are prone to agglomeration; Large particle scattering. High DOI precipitation of barium requires extremely narrow PSD, with D97 closely adhering to D50.
3. Insufficient surface modification or wrong selection of modifier
Non modified: hydrophilic, flocculent and clumping in solvent systems;
Stearic acid modification: cheap, but compared to many acrylic acids PU、 The compatibility of amino resin is average, and it is prone to migration and interface fogging;
High gloss automotive grade: Silane in-situ coating, thin, uniform, low specific surface area, low oil absorption, stable spatial resistance, and no flocculation.
1. High oil absorption value (key indicator). For high gloss DOI, the oil absorption of precipitated barium is generally controlled at 10-16 g/100g; Ordinary precipitated barium often adsorbs a large amount of resin at 20-30 degrees, resulting in insufficient resin in some areas, uneven film shrinkage, microwave patterns, acceptable gloss, and DOI collapse.
2. The residual soluble salts are not thoroughly washed with water, resulting in free Na ⁺, SO ₄² ⁻, later migration, microphase separation, and surface fogging.
3、 Accumulation and deterioration at the formula and process level
1. Insufficient dispersion, powder flocculation of barium sulfate flocs, equivalent to “tiny particle protrusions”, increased shortwave roughness, and DOI cliff drop; The conflict with your pigment dispersion and anti settling system follows the same logic: mismatched dispersants, insufficient shearing, and incorrect feeding sequence.
Phenomenon: The fineness of the fineness board is qualified, but the surface is foggy and the reflection is blurred, which is micro flocculation.
1. PVC is too high, resin is insufficient, and there is too much filler filling. The resin cannot completely wrap the particles, and the particles cannot be filled flat by the resin, resulting in exposed microscopic irregularities.
2. Rheological/anti settling system interference: Strong thixotropy and high yield value anti settling agents (bentonite, some HEUR) prevent settling, but inhibit wet film leveling, lock short wave patterns, and prevent DOI from rising; The high gloss DOI system should have weak thixotropy, low yield, and a long leveling window.
3. Synergistic scattering with titanium dioxide and colored pigments. Titanium dioxide has a refractive index of 2.7 and barium sulfate has a refractive index of 1.64, with overlapping interface scattering between the two; Poor dispersion of barium sulfate can amplify the fogging of titanium dioxide.
4、 Quick distinction: Is it a problem with the powder itself or a dispersion/process issue
Simple comparison board:
Using the same formula, narrow distribution silane modified high gloss precipitated barium resulted in a significant increase in DOI → powder grade issue;
After changing the powder, there is still fog and blurred reflection, which is caused by dispersant, sanding, leveling, solvent evaporation gradient, and anti settling agent rheological problems;
The gloss of 60 ° is very high, but the DOI is low and the reflection is blurry → typical short wave roughness/micro flocculation, not large particle roughness.
5、 Enhancement plan (high gloss/high DOI topcoat direction)
✅ Powder selection
Abandoning natural barium as a high DOI topcoat;
Precipitation barium priority: spherical, narrow particle size distribution, low oil absorption (10-16), in-situ modification with silane, low solubility salt, D97 ≤ 2 μ m (automotive paint grade, such as SK Blanc Fixe micro class);
Do not use stearic acid modified ordinary precipitated barium as a high gloss DOI topcoat.
✅ Dispersion and feeding sequence
1. Pre mix resin, solvent, and dispersant;
2. First, sand the titanium dioxide/colored pigment in place;
3. Add barium sulfate, sufficient for sanding/high shear, to disperse primary aggregates;
4. Finally, add leveling, defoaming, and weak thixotropic anti sinking systems, and avoid strong thixotropic systems.
Barium sulfate should not be directly added as a dry powder, it is best to pre slurry it.
✅ Formula control points
Control the filling amount of barium sulfate and do not pull the PVC too high;
Choose dispersants that match the modified barium sulfate to avoid excessive anions causing flocculation;
Rheology: Prioritize thickening with low yield and long leveling windows, sacrificing some anti settling for DOI; If necessary, a small amount of gas-phase silica should be used in conjunction with bentonite;
Solvent gradient: Slow evaporating solvent provides sufficient leveling time to suppress Benel vortex short wave patterns.
✅ Pit reminder
Many manufacturers only label “high gloss barium sulfate” as having high gloss, which does not necessarily mean high DOI; Only looking at D50 without looking at D97, PSD, oil absorption, and surface treatment types are the most common pitfalls.
Post time: Nov-16-2026



